Romancey Pants

Romance is ducking awesome. And so is diversity. Join us!


The Subtle Art of Not Giving Up (No Doves Involved)

Friends, I recently submitted a manuscript to a category romance line I’m trying to break into. And I heard back! Yes, said the editor, you’re doing great, but—and only if you’re game—I’d love you to rework your first three chapters and outline, and then resubmit. What say you?

Funnily enough, about eight years ago, before I signed with someone else, a dream agent wrote me a very long email saying she loved my novel, had read the whole thing, but really wanted me to extend it. “Sit in your scenes more fully,” she said. “Expand and extend! Because seriously, I want this novel, and I think our sensibilities dovetail.”

Duck: *quacker-gasp* A dove was involved?

Did I rework that novel? No, I did not. I didn’t know where to begin. I liked it the way it was. Going back in felt messy, problematic. Why? Because I didn’t have the self-esteem.

Writerly self-esteem is amazing stuff, right? It says, “Yes, you can!” It says, “Try for it all!” It says, “Reworking is fun!” It says, “Love is worth the commitment!” It says, “It’s all great learning!” It says, “This is how you keep improving!” At least, that’s my experience of writerly self-esteem. Nowadays, of course, I’m out as nonbinary and pansexual, and I’m living a much more authentic life, so my self-esteem is high. It’s astonishing how greatly authenticity can change things.

So, when this kind romance editor reached out to me, suggesting—very thoughtfully with a ton of awesomely brilliant feedback, for which I paid not one mite—that I give those three chapters another go, I saw it for the gift it was. A HUGE, AMAZING, WILDLY GENEROUS GIFT! I’m having a ton of fun redrafting and I’m learning lots, too. And even if the manuscript isn’t right when I resubmit it, it will have been worth every edit.

Duck: So there weren’t any birds involved in this post at all?

Me: Well, you were involved.

Duck: Oh now, you’re just trying to raise my self-esteem!

Wishing you TONS of writerly self-esteem, my friends.



About US

Welcome! I’m Star Tavares. I am queer and nonbinary, and I use they/them pronouns. My hubby Jake is LGBTQIA+ too. Our plush duck is called Duck and is super-ducking awesome. He likes to call himself an award-winning duck because we wrote a screenplay about him that won some awards, and who are we to argue?

The thing is, we used to publish in the romance genres, but after we came out, we thought romance didn’t want us anymore. But you know what, toots? We were wrong.

Now we’ve rebuilt our confidence and are back to living our Romancey Pants life, writing, reviewing romance movies, reading romance novels, and doing a whole lot of stretching. (Did I mention we’re getting older?)

Want to know more about Star’s writing credits? Under another name, Star has published romance stories, novels, and novellas with presses like Harper Collins and Cleis, and has won awards for their shorter works from the likes of Glimmer Train, Screencraft, and Narrative, where they also worked as an editor. More recently, Star’s nonfiction about gender identity has appeared in The New York Times and at Huffington Post Personal.

Since Jake, who is also a romance author, is starting to add more reviews here (along with Duck’s best frenemy Sir Mallard Jones) watch this space for more about him and his career.

Please sign up for our newsletter below and join us at Romancey Pants for romance reviews and personal rambles.

Let’s do this!

Newsletter